Why is constructive feedback difficult in Thailand?

It is difficult due to cultural concepts like 'Face' (dignity) and 'Kreng Jai' (consideration). Thais often avoid direct criticism to prevent causing embarrassment or disrupting group harmony, which can lead to a lack of clear guidance.

What is the 'Sandwich Method' and does it work in Thailand?

The Sandwich Method involves sandwiching negative feedback between positive praise. It works well in Thailand, but the positive 'bread' needs to be substantial and genuine. The corrective part should be framed as a gentle suggestion rather than a harsh demand.

How can I give feedback without causing a loss of face?

Always give feedback in private. Never criticize an employee in front of their peers. Use a soft opener to establish rapport, focus on the work issue rather than the person's character, and use indirect language to suggest improvements.

How does feedback impact employee retention?

Regular, respectful feedback makes employees feel valued and supported in their professional growth. When employees see a clear path to improvement and feel their manager cares about their success, they are significantly more likely to stay with the company.

What role does HR play in building a feedback culture?

HR plays a vital role by training managers in soft skills and cultural sensitivity. They establish systems for regular performance reviews and model open communication, ensuring that feedback becomes a normal, positive part of the employee experience.

Constructive Feedback: What, How, and Examples in Thailand

Rohan Jain
4 วันที่ผ่านมา
ยาว 7 นาที

In the dynamic Thailand labor market, managing a team requires more than just technical expertise. It requires high emotional intelligence and a deep understanding of Thai workplace culture. One of the most difficult challenges for business leaders and hr professionals in Thailand is giving feedback. In many Western cultures, being direct is seen as efficient. In Thailand, being too direct can destroy relationships and cause talented staff to resign unexpectedly.

Yet, silence is not the answer. Without feedback, performance stagnates, and business outcomes suffer. The challenge is not if you should give feedback, but how to give it in a way that builds trust rather than destroying it. Constructive feedback is the bridge between current performance and future potential. When done correctly, it is a powerful tool for talent management, career development, and employee retention.

This guide provides a deep dive into the art of feedback in Thailand. We will explore the cultural nuances of "Face" and "Kreng Jai," provide a step-by-step framework for delivering difficult messages, and show you real-world examples of how to turn criticism into a tool for leadership development.

1. The Business Case: Why Constructive Feedback Culture Matters in Thailand

Many managers in Thailand avoid giving negative feedback because they fear conflict. They worry that the employee will be upset or quit. This avoidance creates a "culture of silence." In this environment, mistakes are repeated, and top performers feel frustrated because the team is not improving.

Implementing a culture of constructive feedback is essential for organizational success. According to global HR studies, organizations with a strong feedback culture can significantly improve employee engagement and productivity (Gallup, 2024). In Thailand, where relationships are the foundation of work, feedback must be reframed. It should not be seen as a punishment. It should be seen as an act of care and support for the employee's professional growth.

When HR teams train managers to give feedback correctly, it leads to:

Higher Retention Rates: Employees stay where they feel they are learning and growing.
Better Business Results: Clear guidance helps team members correct errors and improve their skill set, directly impacting the bottom line.
Higher Employee Satisfaction: Honest, respectful conversations foster a sense of belonging.
Stronger Relationships: This open communication builds trust between managers and staff, which is essential for creating a positive work environment.

2. Decoding the Cultural Context: Face and Kreng Jai

To give effective feedback in Thailand, you must first understand the cultural operating system. Two concepts dictate almost all social interactions in the Thai workplace: "Face" and "Kreng Jai."

The Concept of Face (Na)

"Face" represents a person’s dignity, social standing, and reputation. Preserving face is paramount.

Losing Face (Sia Na): If you criticize an employee publicly or speak to them aggressively, they "lose face." This is a humiliating experience. Once an employee loses face, they often disengage emotionally from the job. In severe cases, they may resign immediately to escape the embarrassment.
Giving Face: A skilled leader knows how to correct a mistake while protecting the employee's dignity. This maintains the relationship and ensures the employee remains receptive to coaching.

The Concept of Kreng Jai

"Kreng Jai" is often translated as "consideration," but it is deeper than that. It is the reluctance to impose on others or cause them discomfort.

The Barrier: A Thai employee might not tell you they are struggling because they do not want to burden you.
The Manager's Dilemma: A Thai manager might avoid giving necessary negative feedback because they do not want to hurt the employee's feelings or disturb the group harmony.

HR professionals must teach managers that constructive feedback does not violate Kreng Jai if it is done privately, politely, and with the intention of helping.

3. The Framework: How to Deliver Feedback Effectively

Blue infographic titled "The Framework: How to Deliver Feedback Effectively" with steps: Privacy, Soft Opener, “We”, Not “You”, Indirect Suggestion. — **The Framework: How to Deliver Feedback Effectively**

Successful feedback in Thailand requires a specific approach. The standard Western "radical candor" often fails here. Instead, use a "Relationship-First" model.

Step 1: Privacy is Non-Negotiable

Never, under any circumstances, give corrective feedback in front of others. Even a mild correction in a meeting can be seen as a public shaming. Always schedule a private meeting. A neutral location, like a coffee shop, can feel less threatening than a formal office.

Step 2: The Soft Opener (The "Pillow")

Do not jump straight to the problem. Thais value the relationship first. Start with small talk. Ask about their family, their lunch, or their weekend. This "pillow" signals that you care about them as a person, not just as a worker. It establishes psychological safety before the hard conversation begins.

Step 3: Focus on the "We," Not the "You"

Direct "You" statements feel accusatory in Thai. Instead of saying "You made a mistake," try to depersonalize the issue. Focus on the work product or the company goals.

Too Direct: "You missed the deadline for the sales report."
Thai Friendly: "The sales report was a bit late this month. This delays the team's ability to plan. How can we adjust the process to make sure it is ready on time next month?"

Step 4: Indirect Suggestion

Instead of giving a direct order ("Fix this now"), frame the correction as a suggestion or a request for help. Use phrases like "It might be better if..." or "Could you help me by..." This allows the employee to accept the feedback without feeling ordered around, which preserves their autonomy and dignity.

4. Real-World Examples: Scenarios and Scripts

Let’s look at how to handle common issues that affect day to day operations using this culturally sensitive approach.

Scenario A: The Chronic Latecomer

The Issue: An employee, Khun Aom, has been arriving 30 minutes late every day, affecting the morning briefing.

The Wrong Way: "Aom, you are late again. This is unprofessional. If you are late tomorrow, I will have to give you a warning letter." (This causes immediate loss of face and resentment).

The Right Way (Constructive): (In private) "Khun Aom, how are you doing today? Is everything okay at home? I noticed you have been coming in a little later recently. I am worried because the team really relies on your input during the morning briefing. We miss your ideas when you aren't there. Is there a traffic issue we can solve? Let’s try to get back to the 9:00 AM start so the whole team can succeed together."

Scenario B: Subpar Work Quality

The Issue: Khun Boyd submitted a presentation that has typos and formatting errors.

The Wrong Way: "This presentation is sloppy. Fix the typos and send it back." (This attacks his competence).

The Right Way (Constructive): (In private) "Khun Boyd, thank you for finishing the draft so quickly. I really like the data you found for slide 5; that is exactly what the client needs and it will have a positive impact on the meeting. To make the final version even stronger, I think we should polish the formatting and double-check the spelling. A perfect report will really impress the client and show off your hard work. Could you help me review it one more time?"

Scenario C: The Passive "Yes"

The Issue: You ask Khun May if she can finish a project by tomorrow. She smiles and says "Yes," but you suspect she is overwhelmed and cannot actually do it. She is saying yes out of Kreng Jai.

The Wrong Way: "Don't just say yes. Be honest. Can you do it or not?" (This corners her and forces a confrontation).

The Right Way (Constructive): "Khun May, this is quite a large task. I want to make sure you don't have to work overtime. What is your current workload like? If we look at the steps, do you think tomorrow is realistic, or would next Tuesday be better for quality? I want you to have enough time to do a good job."

5. The Role of HR in Building Feedback Culture

HR departments play a critical role in shifting organizational culture and improving leadership skills across the company. Feedback skills are not innate; they must be taught.

Training Programs: Invest in soft skills training for all managers. Teach them the difference between criticism and coaching. Role-play these scenarios so they feel comfortable with the language.

Establish Routine: Make feedback regular, not just an annual event. When feedback happens frequently (e.g., weekly check-ins or during performance reviews), it becomes less scary. Regular feedback identifies areas for improvement early, preventing small issues from becoming big problems.

Lead by Example: Business leaders must ask for feedback themselves. When a boss asks, "How can I support you better?", it signals that feedback is a two-way street. It creates a culture of continuous learning.

Conclusion

Giving constructive feedback in Thailand requires a shift in mindset. It is less about "optimizing efficiency" at all costs and more about "optimizing relationships" for long-term gain. When your team members feel safe, respected, and supported, they will be more open to correction. They will work harder to improve because they want to support the team, not just because they fear punishment.

For HR professionals, mastering this skill is essential for retaining top talents. A company that provides growth through kind, clear feedback will always have a competitive advantage in the labor market. You can hold high standards, as long as you deliver them with high respect.

Partnering with Hyperwork Recruitment

Building a high-performance team starts with hiring the right people people who are eager to learn and grow. As Thailand's leading recruitment agency, Hyperwork Recruitment specializes in identifying candidates with the right soft skills and cultural fit for your organization.

We understand the nuances of Thai workplace culture. We help you find qualified candidates who thrive in collaborative environments and respond well to coaching. Whether you need to fill a job opening or consult on HR strategies for retention, we are here to help. Partner with us to build a team that drives your business goals forward.

Connect with us Today!